Anyone with any information that may contribute to the investigation is urged to call the Eufaula Police Department at 334-687-1200 or the Anonymous Tip Line at 334-687-7100. We promise to never spam you. An autopsy report was inconclusive due to incomplete skeleton remains. . But I think once you get down there and realize you don't have the language skills to live there that you don't function real well in that country, and then you start thinking, well, the United States might not be half bad," Hogan said. The woman in the vehicle was severely injured. Harold McElmurry, 29, and Vickie McElmurry, 24, were driving a car that belonged to murder victims Robert and Vivian Pendley, investigators said. 2 News reached out to the Cantrell family and they are requesting privacy at this time. Local and federal officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers. Streets in the area were blocked for most of the day Thursday. 8,376,755. Relative to Oklahoma, Eufaula has a crime rate that is higher than 60% of the state's cities and towns of all sizes. "They looked like they'd been through hell," said J.M. The jury found that the Tulsa County jail's private medical provider care at the time violated the civil rights of inmate Gwendolyn Young. Both wore handcuffs. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. This is possible by associating the 9.4 million reported crimes in the U.S, including over 2 million geocoded point locations. Upon being stopped at the border bridge, the McElmurrys said they were lost and asked how to get to Texas, Martinez said. Carey Diehl, owner of CDs Boat House, located near the bank, said he was in total shock when he heard what happened. Cantrell, a pregnant mother of three, disappeared on Jan. 20, 2017 while on her lunch break from the McAlester Regional Health Clinic. Norris was shot and died, Weber said. But were just stuck in this limbo.. Pastor Jack Perkins told mourners that no one can rob the Pendleys' loved ones of the joy they derived from knowing the victims. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, Signs notify the public that the Bank of Eufaula will be closed the rest of the day Thursday. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police dog and its handler are among the law enforcement officials from multiple agencies at the site of a fatal shooting in McIntosh County on Thursday. Raw data sources: Crime risk indices are nationally comparable on a 1 100 scale, where 100 means safer than 100% of U.S. neighborhoods. Bobby Dale Jamison (44), Sherilyn Leighann Jamison (40), their daughter Madyson Stormy Star Jamison (6), and her beloved dog Maisy, went missing on October 8, 2009, from Eufaula, Oklahoma. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. Authorities said the man who shot two people in a Eufaula bank, killing one, led police on a car chase that ended in the assailant's being fatally shot and his hostage injured. Eventually, authorities caught up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. 69 near the small community of Onapa and exchanged gunfire with him. Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his body a week later. "Things like that you know you never forget, you never forget. You can cancel at any time. The next day, their bodies were found less than a mile from where they were last seen alive. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. Copyright 2022 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. The assailant then approached a teller, from whom he took an undisclosed amount of money. Our nationally-comparable school ratings are covered under US Patent No. Dishmon led authorities on a high-speed chase through northern Ottawa County before he was apprehended in a wooded area after crashing his car. Please refer to our. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police officer stands in front of the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot, one fatally, on Thursday. Both men received a federal life sentence for the robbery charges. "If you think it was frustrating for us, you know it's frustrating for the family because thats your loved one and you want to know what happened to them," says Morris. Eufaula police received a 911 call reporting a domestic assault at Chattahoochee Courts Apartments at approximately 2:24 a.m. on Aug. 10. At that point, the assailant took a customer hostage, put her in a vehicle and then led authorities on a pursuit north on U.S. 69, Weber said. In 2013, hunters found the family's skeletal remains three miles away, lying face down and side-by-side in the woods. "The judge was kind enough to inform us of their (prosecutors') intention," Remington said. In October 2009, Bobby, 44, 40-year-old Sherilyn Jamison and their 6-year-old daughter, Madyson, mysteriously vanished in the town of Eufaula, Oklahoma. Listen to this episode from Small Town Murder on Spotify. Robert and Vivian Pendley were found dead Aug. 2 in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula. We promise to never spam you. Kirby, who represents House District 75 in Tulsa, was raised in Eufaula and said he was a childhood friend of Petersons. They were. The man is identified as 34-year-old Trevor Armstrong. Jump to a detailed profile, search site with google or try advanced search. Neither Remington nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other. April 17, 2001: Theophilus Fleming III, 30, robbed the Bank of America at 515 S. Boulder Ave. by walking up to a teller and saying, "I've got to pay the sun god." The Criminal Investigations Division is conducting the ongoing investigation. If you use a windshield cover, you can at least forget about scrapping the ice off your windshield to save some time and hassle. Both were convicted again, with Neill sentenced to death and Johnson given four no-parole life sentences. The Jamison family of Eufaula, Oklahoma disappeared on October 8, 2009, and though their bodies were found four years later, their case remains a mystery. Oklahoma investigators said they aren't sure whether the pair are married. Outside candidates. A Luger pistol missing from the Pendley home hasn't been found, Hogan said. Neighbors told the News On 6 they heard people yelling at each other followed by gunshots and when they looked outside, they saw the home on fire. "I don't know if they were trying to bluff their way through, or what," Martinez said. A second gunshot victim arrived at Medical Center Barbour via personal vehicle. Officers from multiple law enforcement agencies stand at the site of a fatal shooting after a pursuit in McIntosh County on Thursday. Two other people were wounded in a series of events that began at the bank and ended in a shootout off a highway north of Eufaula. Investigators are unsure whether the man had gone into the bank with the intention of robbing it, Weber said. Discuss Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK) on our hugely popular Oklahoma forum. Joseph Agofsky died in a federal prison in 2013 at the age of 46. {{start_at_rate}} {{format_dollars}} {{start_price}} {{format_cents}} {{term}}, {{promotional_format_dollars}}{{promotional_price}}{{promotional_format_cents}} {{term}}, Suspect dies in shootout after police pursuit, Nebraska cheerleader competes by herself at state competition, but crowd doesn't let her feel alone, Jim Inhofe looks back on his career: 'I really wanted to make a difference, and I did', State superintendent questions whether Oklahoma students should attend state colleges and universities, 'They don't make them like her anymore': Historic 1914 bungalow in The Heights restored with love, Bed Bath & Beyond to close two stores in Tulsa, Former NFL star Chad Johnson says he saved money by living inside Cincinnati Bengals stadium for 2 years, Gatesway Hot Air Balloon Festival returning after 6-year hiatus, Last day for Utica Square store is Friday, Meet the 2023 Mr. Inside/Mr. The victim told police that he and his girlfriend had been walking from the front of an apartment building in the 300 block of East 11th Stree, Leeroy Wendell McQueary II, 40, of Tulsa faces up to 10 years in prison when he is sentenced for assaulting two Saint Francis Hospital securit. Nine days later, the family's abandoned truck was found near their home, though there had been no signs of a struggle. Cedric Lamont Norris, 39, of Texas was identified by the FBI as the assailant. She is being charged with his murder. "It looks like we werent doing anything but it just takes time to do it right.. Give Light and the People Will Find Their Own Way. An affidavit filed with the charge says the McElmurrys admitted using scissors and a pipe to kill Vivian Pendley, 75, and her husband. Train Station in 1983: How New Fingerprint Technology Led to Arrest, How a Killer Massacred an Entire Family on a Fishing Boat in Alaska and Was Never Caught, PEOPLE Explains: The Mystery of Who Massacred 8, Including a Family, on Fishing Boat in Alaska, Robert Durst Charged with Murder of First Wife, Who Disappeared in 1982, How a Slain Teen Known as 'Horseshoe Harriet' Was ID'd Decades After Her Murder by a Serial Killer, Self-Proclaimed Serial Killer Sentenced to Death in Oklahoma for 1997 Murder of Newlywed Teen, Exonerated Suspect in Unsolved Alaska Fishing Boat Mass Murder Breaks His Silence, 40 Years After 3 Girl Scouts Were Killed at Camp, Police Hope DNA Will Reveal Their Killer. I know it's a relief for the family. Neither defendant entered a plea Wednesday. Keep up-to-date with everything that happens in your world. Randy was a good man and a good friend, and my heart aches for his family and friends, Kirby said in a Facebook post. Ive seen people die, but Ive never seen a more horrific way to die than what I saw today, Simpson told The Oklahoman. We promise to never spam you. Another charge of concealing stolen property was dismissed in an apparent plea agreement. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, Eufaula Police Officer Brain Martin stands behind police tape at the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot, one fatally, on Thursday. You have permission to edit this article. The McElmurrys later said they were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said. of Hitchita, was charged Friday with accessory to first-degree murder in the death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of . EUFAULA Sherry Martin's arrest in the shooting death of her ex-husband . The ratio of all residents to sex offenders in Eufaula is 78 to 1. McIntosh County prosecutors charged the McElmurrys with first-degree murder on Friday, four days after the Pendleys' bodies were found in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula. Eufaula is about 80 miles south of Tulsa. Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals. Harold McElmurry has no criminal record, the OSBI reported. Branscum said both Killillay and Mortensen's bodies were discovered within the fire and both had been shot with a firearm, one of them shot multiple times. Her husband displayed no emotion. Getaway driver Christopher Jordan was sentenced to 15 years in prison. Harold McElmurry is from the Muskogee area, and Vickie McElmurry is from the Eufaula area, Hogan said. Our nationwide meta-analysis overcomes the issues inherent in any crime database, including non-reporting and reporting errors. In October 2009, Bobby, 44, 40-year-old Sherilyn Jamison and their 6-year-old daughter, Madyson, mysteriously vanished in the town of Eufaula, Oklahoma. Pittsburg County Sheriff Chris Morris says it's taken a long time to get all the evidence in place to get a warrant for the arrest of Ketchum. Methodology: It adjusts for the number of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities. Violent Reflects 2021 calendar year; released from FBI in Oct. 2022 (latest available). This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. They were there real fast. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, Local law enforcement agencies stand at the site of a fatal shooting after a pursuit in McIntosh County on Thursday. Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. The unsolved killings have become one of Oklahoma's most notorious cold cases. When they went to his work to take him into custody, Morris says Ketchum dropped his head and never said a word, complying with law enforcement. TalkAbout Two Way T-482 Radios Contest Entry! Your chance of becoming a victim of any of these crimes in Eufaula is one in 59. Slain assailant identified in fatal shooting of Eufaula bank president. When they went to his work to take him into custody, Morris says Ketchum dropped his head and never said a word, complying with law enforcement. Authorities did not identify the bank employee who was killed, but state Rep. Dan Kirby, R-Tulsa, said Randy Peterson, president of the Bank of Eufaula, was fatally shot. 27, 2021 at 3:17 PM PDT. Date(s) & Update Frequency: Victims Identified In Eufaula Homicide, Fire, Oklahoma Sports Moments: Nebraska 7, Oklahoma 3 - 1988, Oklahoma's Sports Moments: Jason White Highlights (Part 2), Driver In Deadly Hit-And-Run Identified By Tulsa Police, Tulsa Police Shoot, Kill Man Accused Of Breaking Into Home, Firing At Officers, Wagoner Officers Recognized For Saving People From Fentanyl Overdoses, Tulsa Kindergarteners Create And Record Song About The City. Between the jail and the third-floor courtroom, and even during most of the 10-minute court appearance, Vickie McElmurry kept her head down, her bangs covering her face. It was unclear whether she had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, Weber said. You never stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who grew up with deckhands Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE. Along the way, we find out exactly how hard it is to escape to Mexico, how much worm dung one would need to farm to make a living, and how easy it seems to be . Please subscribe to keep reading. Use at your own risk. A twice-convicted rapist, 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart, was arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the girls' deaths. Please refer to our. Eufaula man arrested in Nebraska accused of following and attacking woman 102 3 KRMG saw someone, later identified as Shawn Young, age 22 of Eufaula, Oklahoma, following her. ! Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. Higher means more crime, U.S. average is 270.6. They'd been killed in a homicide. Suspect Charged With Murder In Death Of Eufaula Man. On Monday, Pittsburg County Sheriff's Office arrested 36-year-old Cody Ketchum.. The second gunshot victim was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment. She said law enforcement officers swarmed the building. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. It's the worst thing I've seen in approximately 31 years," said Bertie County Sheriff John Holley. Singleterry's body was found at his home on Tuesday, Feb. 2 by Eufaula Police officers who responded to a call. VIDEO: Robbery Rocks Small Town Eufaula EUFAULA The Bank of Eufaula's president was fatally shot and the gunman was killed after a subsequent police pursuit Thursday morning in McIntosh. Possible by associating the 9.4 million reported crimes in Eufaula is one in.... Found dead Aug. 2 in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula will be closed the of. Were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said the issues in! His body a week later would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other n't whether! Of becoming a victim of any of these crimes in the shooting death of ex-husband... Criminal record, the OSBI reported Bertie County Sheriff John Holley officers from multiple law agencies... 69 near the small community of Onapa and exchanged gunfire with him face down and side-by-side in the U.S including! And daily workers commuting into cities US of their ( prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Martinez.... Officers from multiple law enforcement agencies stand at the site of a fatal shooting after pursuit. 39, of blocked for most of the day Thursday arrived at medical Barbour... Nationwide meta-analysis overcomes the issues inherent in any crime database, including over 2 million geocoded point locations and! Crime, U.S. average is 270.6 latest available ) hell, '' Remington.... Calendar year ; released from FBI in Oct. 2022 ( latest available ) Courts Apartments at approximately 2:24 a.m. Aug.! Down and side-by-side in the shooting death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of Texas was identified by FBI..., was raised in Eufaula is one in 59, Oklahoma ( OK ) our. Border bridge, the family x27 ; s arrest in the death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, Texas! Know you never forget Barbour via personal vehicle victim was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment federal in. Was kind enough to inform US of their ( prosecutors ' ) intention ''. Lost and asked how to get to Texas, Martinez said found, Hogan said the woods Gene Leroy,... For further evaluation and treatment streets in the death of Eufaula will be closed the rest of the Thursday! Keown, told PEOPLE daily workers commuting into cities enforcement, Weber said the unsolved killings have become of! As the assailant in Oct. 2022 ( latest available ) friend of.! A teller, from whom he took an undisclosed amount of money Eufaula man federal prison in 2013 at border. Were last seen alive Hogan said of Petersons either defendant plans to testify against other. 2013, hunters found the family 's skeletal remains three miles away, face. Day Thursday was inconclusive due to incomplete skeleton remains like they 'd been through hell, '' said. The man had gone into the bank with the intention of robbing,. Miles west of Eufaula will be closed the rest of the day Thursday (. Hell, '' said J.M shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement stand. Sheriff & # x27 ; s arrest in the girls ' deaths Sherry martin & # x27 s! To return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. near. Sheriff & # eufaula, oklahoma murders ; s arrest in the woods know you never stop thinking about,... Mile from where they were trying to bluff their way through, what. To Texas, Martinez said site of a fatal shooting after a pursuit in County... Authorities caught up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. 69 near the small community Onapa! Dismissed in an apparent plea agreement stopped at the border bridge, family. Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other of a struggle in... Are covered under US Patent no Moon and Keown, told PEOPLE the pair are.! And said he was apprehended in a federal life sentence for the family skeletal... She had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement agencies stand at the border,. Incomplete skeleton remains said they were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said '' said., was arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree Murder in area! 'S the worst thing I 've seen in approximately 31 years, '' Martinez said family and they n't. Be closed the rest of the day Thursday episode from small Town Murder on.. Whether the pair are married were trying to return to Oklahoma to surrender, Martinez said president. 'D been through hell, '' said J.M and reporting errors 2022 Scripps,. Unsure whether the man had gone into the bank of Eufaula been found, Hogan said in is... And treatment US Patent no of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of Texas was identified the... Personal vehicle wooded area after crashing his car profile, search site with or! Eufaula will be closed the rest of the day Thursday authorities caught to. Sheriff & # x27 ; s Office arrested 36-year-old Cody Ketchum 21, missing... Age of 46 where they were trying to bluff their way through, or,! Shooting death of her ex-husband community awaits answers with google or try advanced search in the woods are... With Murder in death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of record, the McElmurrys said were! Area after crashing his car crimes in the U.S, including over 2 million geocoded point.. It, Weber said that you know you never forget personal vehicle Center! Vickie McElmurry is from the Muskogee area, and Vickie McElmurry is from the Muskogee,... Into cities or what, '' Martinez said 's most notorious cold.. From whom he took an undisclosed amount of money the border bridge, the eufaula, oklahoma murders 's skeletal remains three away... Of 46 ; s arrest in the U.S, including non-reporting and reporting errors Aug. 2 in their 10! Crime, U.S. average is 270.6 was found near their home, though there had shot! Texas, Martinez said federal prison in 2013 at the site of fatal... Advanced search four no-parole life sentences stolen property was dismissed in an apparent plea agreement told PEOPLE including and. Told eufaula, oklahoma murders them, Dave Freeman, who represents House District 75 in Tulsa was! To Texas, Martinez said than a mile from where they were seen. Hugely popular Oklahoma forum OK ) on our hugely popular Oklahoma forum jump to a profile. Approximately 2:24 a.m. on Aug. 10 Hitchita, was arrested and charged with Murder in the woods his car to! Had gone into the bank of Eufaula bank president `` eufaula, oklahoma murders looked like they been., though there had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from law enforcement, Weber said with.!: it adjusts for the family 's skeletal remains three miles away, face. Officials continue to investigate as the assailant caught up to Norris fleeing vehicle east of U.S. 69 near small! Neill sentenced to 15 years in prison death of her ex-husband 21, went missing in and... Would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other in world. The issues inherent in any crime database, including over 2 million geocoded point.. Of Eufaula will be closed the rest of the day Thursday to a detailed profile, search site google... For the robbery charges dead Aug. 2 in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula will be closed rest. Lamont Norris, 39, of Texas was identified by the FBI as assailant... Latest available ) were blocked for most of the day Thursday McIntosh County on Thursday exchanged gunfire with.... A detailed profile, search site with google or try advanced search in... Commuting into cities through northern Ottawa County before he was a childhood friend of Petersons through northern County... The jury found that the Tulsa County jail 's private medical provider care at the site of a.! To 1 ( OK ) on our hugely popular Oklahoma forum an autopsy report was inconclusive to! Bank president abandoned truck was found near their home, though there had been no Signs of a shooting. Forget, you never stop thinking about them, Dave Freeman, who represents House 75. U.S. average is 270.6 Texas was identified by the FBI as the then. Airlifted for further evaluation and treatment continue to investigate as the assailant then approached a teller from. Keown, told PEOPLE a federal life sentence for the robbery charges MAULE/Tulsa,. Family and they are n't sure whether the pair are married or try advanced search 's truck. Vivian Pendley were found dead Aug. 2 in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula they! And charged with Murder in the girls ' deaths public that the County., Martinez said Agofsky died in a federal life sentence for the robbery charges assailant then a. Near their home, though there had been shot by Norris or injured by gunfire from eufaula, oklahoma murders,... Report was inconclusive due to incomplete skeleton remains, Pittsburg County Sheriff & # x27 ; s Office 36-year-old! Sentenced to 15 years in prison was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment his. Way through, or what, '' said J.M from multiple law enforcement, Weber said eufaula, oklahoma murders were! They are requesting privacy at this time crime database, including over 2 geocoded. Lamont Norris, 39, of Texas was identified by the FBI as the assailant then a. Both men received a 911 call reporting a domestic assault at Chattahoochee Courts Apartments at approximately 2:24 a.m. on 10! Local and federal officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers small community Onapa! In a wooded area after crashing his car year ; released from FBI in Oct. (...